Toll Free:

Live chat
Order now Log In
Toll Free:

Socrates’ Argument: Life of the Just

Socrates’ Argument: Life of the Just

In The Republic, Book I by Plato, Socrates is ambitiously set on showing and proving that just people are happier than unjust ones. Despite Socrates’ sound argument that justice is like a virtue or a skill (349b), it is strongly believed that the statement in question cannot be evaluated as valid or invalid based on the reasoning that takes place in the original step-by-step explanation. It can be concluded that Socrates’ argument is rather weak, does not fully prove the point and needs support to be validated. In this paper, Socrates’ premises that prove the statement will be evaluated, and explanation why the argument would be valid only if adjusted and accompanied by further justification will be provided.

Socrates is arguing that justice is a virtue and a power that is meant to bring harmony among people. His argument consists of the following premises:

  1. The just man is wise and good while the unjust one is considered to be ignorant and, for instance, bad (349b).
  2. Justice is powerful and valuable.
  3. Injustice causes disharmony, hatred, and dissension that affect the right cause of actions among a group (351b).
  4. Justice is avirtue that determines how things function, and an unjust person does not live a happier life in comparison with a just one.

The matter of the just living a happier life than the unjust as argued by Socrates may lose validity if based on the original premises. However, the point, in this case, cannot be convincing and self-justifiable without further evaluation of the reasoning in the premises.

Socrates’ argument concerning the question of justice being a source of might and the unjust being bad people and enemies of themselves cannot be convincing enough based on the first two premises which lack reasoning to support their accuracy and presumably are a mere assumption (Irwin, 1995).

Socrates advances his defense to prove the validity of the just living a good life by claiming that justice leads to friendship and harmony within a group that aims at achieving a common set of objectives. For instance, the example of thieves keeping together due to fear and obligations they have toward one another, is supported by the third premise (351c 7-10). Socrates argues that justice among the gang is what produces co-operation that leads to the achievement of their unjust goals (352a 3). More so, if Socrates claims that justice is what keeps the gang together, then it is hard to understand the reason behind the unjust act of theft. As far as we know, thieves do not have any knowledge on the matter of justice within themselves as a gang, but what we believe is that they keep together due to the fear of one another or the gang’s leader (Lycos, 1987).

Considering the defense of justice as a virtue by Socrates as in the forth premise (352d), he claims that justice is a virtue not of the body, but of the soul. The soul refrains from doing certain things due to adherence to certain rules to achieve common goals. For instance, the ruler of a bad soul rules his citizens badly and may enslave them and other cities. Socrates probably means that a bad soul can yield no positive results in the course of actions due to its corruption.

Justice, as a powerful virtue of the soul which entails doing right and meeting one’s obligations, which, in return, make a person happy, can be absurd if it is beneficial only to another person, not the one performing the act. Thus, the argument of Socrates can be valid only after a little rephrasing given that justice is a virtue beyond mere wisdom.



We offer original custom essays in a wide range of subjects. No matter the topic, you will get an impressive essay.


Discussion Board Post

If you want to get the best discussion board post at an affordable price, just apply to our experts for help.


Research paper

If you experience any difficulties in writing research papers, welcome to us. We produce unique academic papers only!



Ask our experienced and highly educated writers to help you write your coursework, and you will get an impeccable and original paper.


Case Study

Use case study writing services offered by our reputable company. We guarantee to deliver only premium papers.



You can buy a unique questions-answers essay from our custom writing agency online. Hire us to help you succeed!


Powerpoint Presentation

Every time you are looking for a place to purchase a high-quality and creative PowerPoint presentation, visit our website.


Term paper

If you need help in writing a quality term paper, contact us. Our skilled writers specialize in creating authentic papers.


Response paper

Hire our experienced writers to produce a perfectly written response paper for you. We are dedicated to your success.



Use the first-class custom formatting service provided by our diligent experts. We can help you format papers in all styles.


Research proposal

If you do not know how to write a research proposal, make use of our superb research proposal writing services whenever you need.



Order a dissertation written by a professional PhD writer. You will be completely satisfied with your piece of writing.


Article Review

When writing an original article review turns out a difficult task for you, entrust it to our professionals to do it in no time.


Literary analysis

If you need expert assistance in writing a literary analysis essay, choose our reliable service to do the job. Order your essay now!



We can help you paraphrase any of your academic papers. Thus, if you need rewriting help, use our services and get high grades.


Reaction paper

Forget about reaction paper writing difficulties! Ask our qualified writers to help you express unique thoughts and reactions on the subject.


Excel Exercises

Leave the details of your Excel assignment to our competent writers, and they will do it professionally and fast, no matter its difficulty.


Annotated Bibliography

Acquire our remarkable annotated bibliography writing services! We charge the most affordable prices and never compromise on quality.


Business Report

In case you need professional assistance with business report writing, turn to our company. We will provide you with a flawless paper.



Purchase a well-structured and unique outline from us online, and get a brilliant paper. We write custom outlines to all papers.

Limited Time Offer
Your 1st Order
Online - please click here to chat